The car I picked up had quite a few scratches and dents, but that seems pretty normal for cars on this island. The rental company will probably get them fixed and they do keep records of existing damage, so as long as you don’t add any new scratches or bumps when you return it, you’re fine. Just make sure to take plenty of photos when you pick up the car so you’ve got proof of the original condition.

Overall service was satisfactory, and the vehicle's exterior was briefly inspected during return.

Excellent

Horrible, never again. I was pushed into purchasing an insurance worth several hundred euros because I was a female traveling alone-- the gentleman next to me picked up his car without insurance no problems.